Along with MHC class I (MHCI), 2B4 provides nonredundant NK-cell inhibition in mice. The immunoregulatory role of 2B4 has been increasingly appreciated in models of tumor and viral infection, however, the interactions among 2B4, MHCI, and other activating NK-cell receptors remain uncertain. Here, we dissect the influence of two distinct inhibitory pathways in modulating NK-cell-mediated control of tumors expressing strong activating ligands, including RAE-1. In vitro cytotoxicity and in vivo peritoneal clearance assays using MHCI+CD48+ (RMA-neo), MHCI+CD48+RAE-1 (RMA-RAE-1), MHCI-CD48+ (RMA-S-neo), and MHCI-CD48+RAE-1 (RMA-S-RAE-1) tumor lines demonstrated that NKG2D activation supersedes the inhibitory effect of both 2B4- and MHCI-mediated immune-tolerance systems. Furthermore, 2B4KO mice subcutaneously challenged with RMA-neo and RMA-S-neo exhibited reduced tumor growth and significantly prolonged survival compared with WT mice, implying that 2B4 is constitutively engaged in the NK-cell tolerance mechanism in vivo. Nevertheless, the inhibitory effect of 2B4 is significantly attenuated when NK cells encountered highly stressed tumor cells expressing RAE-1, resulting in an immune response shift toward NK-cell activation and tumor regression. Therefore, our data highlight the importance of the 2B4-mediated inhibitory system as an alternate self-tolerance mechanism, whose role can be modulated by the strength of activating receptor signaling within the tumor microenvironment.